Bufala Negra Cocktail Recipe

Bufala Negra Cocktail Recipe: Master the Mix

Our star cocktail today is the exotic Bufala Negra. This captivating concoction seamlessly merges the warmth of bourbon with the tang of balsamic vinegar reduction, the sweetness of brown sugar, the bite of ginger beer, and the fragrant notes of fresh basil leaves.

Originating from the creative mind of mixologist Jerry Slater, Bufala Negra provides a dance of complex, yet perfectly balanced flavors on your palate. It's a delightful exploration of tastes that's ideal for an intimate gathering or a quiet evening at home. Get ready to experience this unique cocktail that takes bourbon drinks to an entirely new level. Let's dive into the recipe!

Related: Bourbon Cocktails

How to make a Bufala Negra cocktail

Creating a Bufala Negra is an art that embraces the balance of sweet, sour, and bold flavors. This enticing bourbon-based cocktail comes to life by expertly muddling basil leaves and a brown sugar cube, blending in a rich balsamic reduction, and finishing off with a hit of zesty ginger beer. With each step meticulously crafted, the making of a Bufala Negra is not just about mixing a drink, it's about stirring up an experience that tantalizes the palate and sparks the senses.


  • 1 saucepan
  • 1 cocktail shaker or mixing glass


  • 4 fresh basil leaves
  • 1 cube brown sugar
  • 1 oz balsamic vinegar reduction
  • 2 oz bourbon - We suggest Fat Baby Bourbon
  • 2 oz ginger beer
  • 1 slice buffalo mozzarella for garnish (optional)
  • 1 sprig of basil for garnish (optional)


  1. Start by making a balsamic reduction. Pour 1 cup of balsamic vinegar into a small saucepan over medium heat. Let it come to a gentle boil, then reduce the heat to low and let simmer, stirring occasionally, until it reduces by half. This should take about 15-20 minutes. Once the reduction is thick enough to coat the back of a spoon, remove it from heat and let it cool.
  2. In a sturdy mixing glass or cocktail shaker, muddle the basil leaves and sugar cube together. The goal is to crush the basil so it releases its oils and combines it with the sugar.
  3. Add the balsamic reduction to the glass. Be careful to only add 1 ounce. While the reduction is a key ingredient in this drink, adding too much can overpower the other flavors.
  4. Pour in the bourbon.
  5. Fill the mixing glass with ice and stir well to combine all of the flavors. The cold from the ice will also help to further break down the sugar cube.
  6. Strain the cocktail into a glass filled with fresh ice.
  7. Top with the ginger beer, and stir gently to combine.
  8. If desired, garnish with a small slice of buffalo mozzarella and a sprig of basil on the rim of the glass.
  9. Serve immediately and enjoy!

Recipe notes

Balsamic Reduction: It's very important not to rush the balsamic reduction. Letting it simmer on low heat will ensure it thickens properly without burning. If you prepare it in advance, the reduction can be stored in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to a month.

Bourbon: The choice of bourbon can greatly impact the overall flavor of your cocktail. A full-bodied, robust bourbon like Fat Baby bourbon would work best in this recipe to stand up against the intense flavors of balsamic reduction and ginger beer.

Basil Leaves: When muddling the basil leaves, be careful not to over-muddle as it can make the basil bitter. The goal is to just bruise the leaves enough to release their essential oils.

Ginger Beer: It is used to add a spicy kick and a bit of fizz to the cocktail. But remember, ginger beer is non-alcoholic despite the name. Don't substitute it with ginger ale, which is much sweeter and less spicy.

Buffalo Mozzarella Garnish: Although this garnish may seem unconventional for a cocktail, it's an homage to the name 'Bufala Negra'. It can provide a unique, creamy contrast to the cocktail's acidity. However, it's completely optional.

Adjustments: Feel free to adjust the recipe to suit your taste. If you find the drink a bit too tart for your liking, you can add a bit more brown sugar. If it's too sweet, a little more balsamic reduction or bourbon might be in order.

Remember, the best cocktails are often the ones tailored to your own personal preferences. Happy mixing!

Ingredient substitutes

  1. Basil Leaves: If you don't have fresh basil leaves, you could use fresh mint leaves for a different but equally refreshing flavor. Alternatively, if you only have dried basil, use a third of the amount called for in the recipe as dried herbs are more potent than fresh.
  2. Bourbon: If bourbon is not available, you can substitute it with another type of whiskey or even a dark rum. The flavor profile will change, but it could create a delightful variant of the Bufala Negra.
  3. Brown Sugar Cube: Regular white sugar cubes can be used in place of brown sugar cubes, or even a teaspoon of granulated brown or white sugar if cubes aren't available.
  4. Balsamic Reduction: If you're short on time, a store-bought balsamic glaze can be used in place of homemade balsamic reduction. Or in a pinch, you could use a rich, dark fruit syrup or a berry compote reduction as an alternative.
  5. Ginger Beer: If you can't find ginger beer, you can substitute it with a strong ginger ale. Keep in mind, however, that ginger beer is spicier and less sweet than ginger ale, so the cocktail's flavor will differ. Another substitute could be a mix of club soda and fresh ginger juice for a similar spice level.

Substituting ingredients will alter the taste of the original recipe, but experimenting could also lead to discovering a new variant of the Bufala Negra that you might enjoy even more.

Bufala Negra cocktail top down view

Best bourbons for Bufala Negra

Crafting an extraordinary Bufala Negra largely depends on the bourbon selected, given its role as the cocktail's base spirit. Here are some distinct and somewhat off-the-beaten-path bourbons that can elevate your cocktail to a new level:

  1. Fat Baby Bourbon: As the top choice, Fat Baby Bourbon, a small-batch, craft bourbon, leads the way in making a standout Bufala Negra. It brings a rich tapestry of caramel and vanilla flavors tied together by an oak spice finish, which marries seamlessly with the balsamic reduction and ginger beer.
  2. Buffalo Trace: Buffalo Trace is an excellent second choice due to its expert balance of sweet, spicy, and fruity flavors that heighten the Bufala Negra's complexity. Its subtle notes of caramel and vanilla harmonize with the tartness of the balsamic vinegar, infusing the cocktail with a creamy dimension.
  3. Elijah Craig Small Batch: This premium, small-batch bourbon provides a full-bodied flavor profile that nicely complements the robust notes of the balsamic reduction. With hints of toasted oak, nutty chocolate, and lush orchard fruits, Elijah Craig adds a sophisticated depth to the Bufala Negra.
  4. High West American Prairie Bourbon: This blend of straight bourbons is known for its rich honey and floral nuances that can counterbalance the balsamic vinegar's tanginess. High West's earthy, herbal undertones also play well with the fresh basil, providing a delightful complexity.
  5. Russell's Reserve 10-Year-Old: Aged for 10 years, Russell's Reserve imparts a unique, smooth character to the Bufala Negra with its nuanced flavors of dried fruit, toffee, and oak spice. Its rich, mellow nature enhances the balance of sweet, sour, and herbal elements in the cocktail.

While these bourbons provide a guideline, the best bourbon for your Bufala Negra will be the one that suits your personal taste preference. Remember, cocktail crafting is an art form and an exploration of flavor, so feel free to experiment.

Related: Fat Baby Blog

Best ginger beers for Bufala Negra cocktail

The choice of ginger beer can significantly impact the overall flavor balance. Here are some of the best ginger beers that complement this unique bourbon cocktail wonderfully:

  1. Fever-Tree Premium Ginger Beer: Known for its fresh, natural ginger flavor, Fever-Tree offers a refreshing balance of sweetness and spiciness. Its robust ginger bite and slight citrus notes work wonderfully to enhance the Bufala Negra's tangy balsamic and warm bourbon flavors.
  2. Bundaberg Ginger Beer: An Australian favorite, Bundaberg is crafted with locally sourced ginger and cane sugar. Its rich, earthy ginger flavor and light fizziness provide the Bufala Negra with an inviting effervescence and an authentic, spicy kick.
  3. Q Mixers Ginger Beer: Q Mixers is a great choice for those who prefer a less sweet ginger beer. With its bold, peppery ginger flavor and lower sugar content, it brings an added complexity to the Bufala Negra while allowing the bourbon to shine.
  4. Reed's Extra Ginger Brew: Reed's provides a potent ginger punch thanks to its recipe, which includes 26 grams of fresh ginger. This, combined with its hint of tropical spices, adds an exciting depth and spicy warmth to the Bufala Negra.
  5. Gosling’s Ginger Beer: Known primarily for its role in Dark 'n Stormy cocktails, Gosling’s also works wonderfully in a Bufala Negra. Its gentle sweetness, spicy ginger profile, and smooth carbonation strike a balance that complements the cocktail's unique flavor profile.

The best ginger beer for your Bufala Negra will ultimately depend on your personal preference for sweetness and spiciness. So, don't hesitate to try different brands until you find the one that suits your taste the best.

Bufala Negral cocktail final thoughts

Crafting the perfect Bufala Negra is an adventure of flavors, a delightful dance of sweet, sour, and spicy notes that delight the palate. It's about discovering the nuances that each ingredient, be it the craft bourbon, the rich balsamic reduction, the vibrant basil, or the fiery ginger beer, brings to the table. 

With our suggested options, from the Fat Baby Bourbon and Buffalo Trace to Fever-Tree and Bundaberg ginger beers, you're equipped to experiment and find your personal preference. So, roll up your sleeves, gather your ingredients, and start mixing. 

The joy of mixology is in the journey as much as it is in the delectable sip of your carefully crafted Bufala Negra. Here's to a splendid mixing experience and a memorable journey through flavor town. Cheers!

Bufala Negra FAQs

What is a Bufala Negra? 

Bufala Negra is a unique bourbon-based cocktail that combines the sweet and spicy flavors of bourbon, balsamic reduction, ginger beer, and a muddled brown sugar cube and basil leaves. This combination of ingredients results in a harmonious balance of sweet, sour, and slightly spicy flavors.

Can I substitute the bourbon in a Bufala Negra? 

Yes, you can substitute the bourbon in a Bufala Negra with other types of whiskey or dark rum. However, be aware that this will change the cocktail's flavor profile. If you're looking for a bourbon alternative that retains a similar flavor, consider using a full-bodied, robust dark spirit.

Can I use regular vinegar instead of balsamic reduction? 

Regular vinegar is not recommended as a substitute for balsamic reduction in a Bufala Negra. Balsamic reduction has a unique, sweet, and tangy flavor that significantly contributes to the cocktail's character. If you don't have balsamic vinegar to make a reduction, you could potentially use a store-bought balsamic glaze.

Can I use ginger ale instead of ginger beer? 

While both ginger ale and ginger beer have ginger flavor, they are quite different. Ginger beer is non-alcoholic but has a much stronger, spicier ginger flavor compared to ginger ale, which is typically sweeter and milder. Substituting ginger beer with ginger ale would result in a less spicy and sweeter cocktail.

Can I make a non-alcoholic version of the Bufala Negra?

Yes, you can create a non-alcoholic version of the Bufala Negra, often referred to as a "mocktail". Replace the bourbon with a non-alcoholic bourbon substitute or even apple juice for a bit of sweetness. Keep in mind that the flavor will not be the same as the alcoholic version, but it can still be a refreshing and flavorful drink.

← Older Post Newer Post →